How to Knit Buttonholes

To knit a buttonhole, pair a yarn over with a decrease for a small opening, or bind off stitches and cast them back on for a larger slit. The yarn-over method is the easiest place to start, while a reinforced one-row buttonhole gives larger buttons a firmer opening. Choose your method on a swatch, then check the fit with the actual button before working the garment.

How Knitted Buttonholes Work

A knitted buttonhole creates an opening without permanently changing your stitch count. In a yarn-over buttonhole, the yarn over adds a stitch and the decrease removes one. In a bound-off buttonhole, new cast-on stitches replace the stitches removed.

The right size depends on your yarn, gauge, stitch pattern, and button, not just the button’s diameter. Knitted fabric stretches, so an opening that looks smaller than the button can still fit well.

“Horizontal” buttonholes run across the stitches on your needle. Their orientation on the finished garment depends on which direction the button band is knitted.

How to Knit Buttonholes Step by Step

Compare buttonhole methods by their best uses and construction trade-offs:

Method Best Use Main Consideration
Yarn-over buttonhole Small buttons and simple borders Easy to work, but limited in size
Simple bound-off buttonhole A wider opening with straightforward construction Backwards-loop cast-on stitches can leave a loose corner
Reinforced one-row buttonhole Larger buttons or a firmer, tidier edge Requires slipping stitches and cable casting on
No-cut afterthought buttonhole A finished band that needs a small opening Works only if the fabric can open without serious distortion

Step 1: Prepare Your Materials and Swatch

  1. Gather your project yarn, knitting needles, intended buttons, removable stitch markers, and a tapestry needle.
  2. Knit a swatch in the actual button-band pattern. A stockinette swatch will not accurately represent a ribbed or garter-stitch border.
  3. Wash and block the swatch as you intend to care for the finished garment, then let it dry before measuring.

Match the button choice to the yarn and gauge. At a fine gauge, smaller buttons placed more frequently may work better than large buttons requiring wide openings that are more prone to stretching.

Step 2: Estimate the Opening Size

  1. For a flat sew-through button, place it on the blocked swatch.
  2. Align its left edge with a column of knit stitches.
  3. Count across to the farthest sewing hole in the button. That count gives a starting estimate for the opening’s width.

This blocked-swatch sizing approach estimates the opening from the finished fabric rather than assuming it should equal the button’s full diameter.

For a shank button or a button without visible sewing holes, make a trial opening and test the button directly. Thickness and shape affect how easily it passes through.

Treat any estimate as a starting point. The button should pass with a snug push, without forcing the fabric badly out of shape.

Step 3: Mark the Buttonhole Position

  1. Lay the button band flat and identify where the opening should sit.
  2. For a horizontal buttonhole near an outer edge, leave at least 3–4 stitches between the corner of the opening and the selvage. This leaves enough fabric to support the opening and helps prevent a bumpy, fast-wearing edge.
  3. Check the position with the fronts overlapping as they will when fastened.

A button tends to settle into the outer corner of a horizontal slit under fastening tension. Allow for that movement rather than automatically centering the empty slit on the intended button line. The aim is for the button to look centered when worn, not merely for the unfastened opening to look centered.

Step 4: Work a Small Yarn-Over Buttonhole

A common 1-stitch buttonhole is YO, k2tog, or YO, p2tog where a purl decrease better suits the border. Confirm the choice against the stitch pattern at the buttonhole location.

  • YO means yarn over.
  • k2tog means knit two stitches together.
  • p2tog means purl two stitches together.

To work the opening:

  1. Knit or purl in pattern up to the marked location.
  2. Make the yarn over before a knit decrease by starting with the yarn at the back. Bring the yarn forward between the needle tips, then take it over the right needle to the back. For a purl decrease, start with the yarn at the front, take it over the right needle to the back, then bring it forward between the tips.
  3. Work the appropriate decrease through the next pair of stitches.
  4. Continue across the row in the established pattern.
  5. On the following row, work the yarn over as an ordinary stitch in the border pattern, without twisting it closed.

Moving the yarn between the needles alone does not make a yarn over. There must be a new loop over the needle.

Step 5: Finish and Check the Opening

  1. Complete enough fabric beyond the opening to let it settle into the border.
  2. Check that the stitch count is unchanged.
  3. Finish the swatch or band, bind off as the pattern requires, and weave in the ends.
  4. Wash and block it, let it dry, and test the intended button.

If the opening is too small, choose a bound-off buttonhole rather than forcing the button through. If it is too loose, adjust the button choice or buttonhole construction before committing to the garment.

How to Knit a One-Row Buttonhole

Choose the width based on your button; for example, bind off 4 stitches. Confirm the exact width on an already blocked swatch with the intended button.

“One-row” means that the lower edge and replacement stitches are completed during the same row. You still work the following row normally to incorporate the new stitches into the fabric.

Simple Bound-Off Buttonhole

The simple bound-off buttonhole uses an ordinary bind-off and a backwards-loop cast-on. Practice it on your border swatch first.

  1. Work to the opening. Knit or purl in pattern to the planned start of the buttonhole.
  2. Bind off the opening. For the small slit used here, knit the next pair of stitches and lift the first over the second. Knit the following stitch and lift the previous stitch over it. You have bound off 2 stitches; the surviving stitch remains on the right needle.
  3. Return the surviving stitch. Slip it back to the left needle without twisting it.
  4. Replace the missing stitches. Backwards-loop cast on 2 stitches onto the right needle. For each stitch, twist the working yarn into a loop, place that loop on the needle, and snug it enough to match the surrounding stitches.
  5. Continue the row. Knit the returned stitch, then resume the border pattern. Keep the first stitch beyond the opening firm without pulling the cast-on loops tight.
  6. Work the following row. Work the new cast-on stitches in the established pattern.
  7. Finish and test. Complete the band, bind off as required, weave in the ends, and block it. Test the button after the fabric has dried.

Backwards-loop stitches can become loose if you spread the needle tips far apart while working into them. Keep the tips close together as you work across the new loops.

Reinforced One-Row Buttonhole

The reinforced one-row buttonhole wraps the beginning of the opening and uses an extra cast-on stitch to anchor the other end. It is useful when a simple bound-off buttonhole leaves a loose loop that catches on the button.

  1. Work to the opening. Continue in pattern to the buttonhole position.
  2. Wrap the starting stitch. Bring the yarn to the front, slip the next stitch purlwise to the right needle, then take the yarn to the back.
  3. Bind off without knitting. Slip the next stitch purlwise and pass the previous slipped stitch over it. Continue slipping a stitch and passing the previous stitch over until the chosen number of stitches has been bound off.
  4. Turn the work. Slip the surviving stitch from the right needle back to the left needle, then turn.
  5. Restore the opening. Cable-cast on the number of stitches that were bound off plus 1 additional stitch. Count the stitches actually bound off, not all the stitches you slipped.
  6. Make the cable cast-on. Insert the right needle between the first and second stitches on the left needle, draw a new loop through, and place it on the left needle. Repeat, always working between the newest stitch and its neighbor. On the final cast-on stitch, bring the yarn to the front between the needles before placing the new loop on the left needle.
  7. Anchor the far end. Turn the work back. Slip the next stitch from the left needle to the right needle, then pass the extra cast-on stitch over that slipped stitch.
  8. Resume the pattern. Continue across the row. On the following row, work the new stitches into the established border pattern and check the stitch count.
  9. Finish and test. Complete and bind off the band as required, weave in the ends, and block it. Once dry, check that the button passes through without catching either corner.

The extra cast-on stitch is removed during the anchoring step.

How to Add an Afterthought Buttonhole Without Cutting

A no-cut afterthought buttonhole enlarges an existing opening in the knitted fabric and reinforces its edges with sewn buttonhole stitches. It suits a small button and a band whose stitches can move enough to form an opening.

Do not force this method into dense fabric or use it to make a large slit. If the band puckers or the surrounding stitches become noticeably distorted, a smaller button or a reworked band is the better choice.

  1. Mark the opening. With the finished band relaxed, mark the intended button position.
  2. Open the stitch gently. Use a blunt tapestry needle to ease apart the center of a knit stitch. Redistribute slack from neighboring stitches rather than pulling sharply on the yarn. Test whether the button can pass before reinforcing anything.
  3. Prepare the edging thread. Thread a tapestry needle with smooth matching yarn or suitable strong thread. Leave a tail that can be woven into the finished edging.
  4. Anchor at the lower side. Pass the needle under the left leg of the enlarged stitch. Pass under that leg again, leaving a loop of edging thread, then bring the needle through the loop and snug it.
  5. Work up the side. Continue passing under the edge strand and through the loop of edging thread before tightening each stitch. Keep the knots facing the opening, and work over the starting tail where practical.
  6. Shape the top. To widen the top for a larger button, work 4 or more buttonhole stitches over the 2 bars above the opening, catching the bars together. Keep the edging snug enough to support the opening without gathering the band.
  7. Complete the edging. Continue down the opposite side and around the base. Secure the final stitch through the starting edging stitch.
  8. Finish the thread. Weave the ends through the reinforced edge on the reverse and trim only the loose edging-thread tails, not the knitted fabric.
  9. Test the closure. Let the band relax, then pass the button through. Check that the opening holds its shape and the surrounding fabric lies flat.

How to Check Buttonhole Fit and Prevent Stretching

A buttonhole must hold its shape under fastening tension, not just let the button pass.

Before knitting the garment’s buttonholes, one guide recommends putting the button through the sample opening 10 or 20 times, then washing the swatch and repeating. This repeated fit test reveals stretching that a single pass may miss.

Check the sample in both its relaxed and fastened positions:

  • The button passes through without snagging.
  • The opening relaxes after the button is removed.
  • The button stays fastened under the gentle tension expected in use.
  • The surrounding fabric does not pucker.
  • The outer edge does not curl or develop an enlarged loop.
  • The border pattern remains correct.

Fix a Hole That Is Too Loose

First distinguish an oversized opening from slack at a corner. An oversized opening remains loose across its width; a corner problem usually shows as an isolated loop.

For a slightly oversized finished opening, use matching yarn to sew the edge stitches together at one end, shortening the usable slit. Secure the yarn, weave in the ends, and test the button again.

For a loose corner, use a tapestry needle to ease the excess yarn into neighboring stitches rather than pulling it into another large loop. Let the fabric relax and test again. If the opening still grows, remake it with a firmer construction.

Fix a Hole That Is Too Tight

Check whether the yarn over was accidentally worked through a leg that twisted it closed. If so, undo the affected work, remake the stitch untwisted, then finish, block, and test the opening.

If the construction is correct but the button still strains the fabric, choose a smaller button or reknit the opening wider. Do not cut a strand to enlarge it; that can release stitches and unravel the band.

Once the sample passes these checks, use its construction for the garment. Finish the bands before marking the final button positions with the fronts aligned.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do You Knit Buttonholes in 2×2 Ribbing?

Place the opening within a matching pair of knit or purl stitches in the k2, p2 repeat. Work YO, k2tog in a knit pair, or YO, p2tog in a purl pair, then resume the established rib columns rather than restarting the repeat. On the return row, work the yarn over untwisted as needed to maintain those columns. Finish and block the band, then test the button, because the opening will interrupt the rib locally even when the stitch count is correct.

How Do You Knit Buttonholes in Garter Stitch?

For a small garter-stitch buttonhole, knit to the intended position, work YO, k2tog, then knit to the end of the row. On the next row, knit the yarn over without twisting it closed and continue in garter stitch. Finish the band, bind off, weave in the ends, and block it before testing the button.

What Is the Standard Spacing for Buttonholes?

There is no universal standard spacing for knitted buttonholes. Mark the top and bottom fastening positions first, then distribute the remaining openings evenly between them. Check the arrangement with the garment fronts overlapped, adjusting the plan where the fabric needs more support to prevent gaping.